Yarin-r Vs Edgar90

first 7 wins....

Yarin-R



Edgar90

 

i go with edgar sign because she more beautiful and animated nicely...
0-1

 

Bahh, I don't see edgars. You might want to fix that.

[EDIT] Ahh, now I can see it. Okay well I vote Edgars. His I feel has a good texture though bright. I like his opacity bar animation in that as well. Yarin, yours is good but to me I think it is a little dull. Nice text and using the render to see the reflection of itself.

 

now its a ok!!!!!

 

I vote Yarin-R, animation ALWAYS kills the sig. 1-2 Edgar

 

Voted for Yarin-R. I thought Edgars was too high in contrast.

[2]-[2]

 

I like Yarin-R's sig. The text is nice and the colours are all balanced nicely.
Edgar90, for me your sig's contrast is much too high. Also, there are soooo many cool effects you can achieve with the scanbar and you didn't really take advantage of them IMO.

Yarin-R - Edgar90
3 - 2

 

IM gonna have to go with Edger, personly i like anamtion.

3-3

 

I vote for: Yarin-R
Reason: I like
Score:
[4] Yarin-R [3] Edgar

both are really nice though

 

what effects???

 

more votes please

 

I vote Yarin-R...

The animation in Edgar's sig is seperatiin the render from the BG in a way that makes it look like it is just stuck on there...


Score:
[5] Yarin-R [3] Edgar

 

Edgar takes my vote: Edgar90:4 Yarin-R:5

 

i vote for YaRiN-R
Edgar90: 4 YaRiN-R: 6

 

more votes please