Wallpaper Challenge (round One)

Heh, this is getting good.
First person I battled with where I didn't get every vote.

 

....cap is jealous LOL..

 

I like BigAFair's better. I like the colors, and the lightning in the wallpaper.

4-4

 

gotta go for irell..i dont like big's tetx

 

Simplicity is nice, but it's just not working this time Irrell. I'm not too fond of either, but Big's get's my vote.
5-5

 

Irrel, bigfare's is out of order, he used the same brush over and over, and it is messy. the colors on his arent the best, and the render is sloppy, and could use some better material.

 

i also would have to vote for irrel, b/c its so clean and u just cant help but look at it twice...
7-5 irrel

 

vote irrel love the wallpaper and really original

 

second that
4-4

 

OMg what a Nice BG !!!

lol realy would not compete with him ....

 

well, I lost score but I vote BIG's.

Irrel's is just TOO simple, simple can be good sometimes but this is not good. Sorry.

I can't help to think that some people are just voting on Irrel because of his reputation as a good sig/wallpaper/... maker. Could be wrong though

 

I vote for BIG. Even though Irrel's one is very original, I don't really like the style. The background of BIG's is awesome!

 

seems to be 8-8

 

i looove the one from [xbox] BIG

 

Irrel's. So simple so luvly. Original =)