Assassins Creed is anything but a "Rent" Game. Anyways, since I own both Assassins Creed + SMG... Vote for AC, definetely. Gameplay, graphics, AI, everything is great. Galaxy's ok at best. (Previous Mario games were better, heck, get Mario Party 8)
It is because after you beat it, your not going to play it but once or twice. So why shell out $60 when you get about the same experience for about $12(2 week rental). SMG is the same way, but its the same as just about every other super mario game.
ac definitely.. that game rocks. but from what i hear, neither seems like a game you would play after you beat it.
no id go with SMG simply because its much more fun to play and is less serious than AC dont get me wrong AC is a great game and well worth buying but SMG is just more fun, for me anyway
I really have to disagree with the "Lack of replay" value on AC. It's going to remain one of my top 360 games for a while simply due to "Pick up and play" viability. Heck, I played for about 8 hours straight and got...what, 1.5 assassinations done? Ruthelessly Murdering citizens doesn't get old, and it's going on the top shelf with Dead Rising and Oblivion.