1st, 8/10, cool render and brushing but the text looks a bit wonky imo 2nd 9.5/10 almost a perfect manip, the white scanlines(i think) detract a little 3rd- 7/10, alright manip, nuthin special though 4th 6/10 too dark and could use a bit more contrast
one on the left is a little bright, but good at the same time 7/10 one on the left is better, very well blended and brushed 8/10
Only rating top one... 9/10 Love the background and colors. Only thing preventing it from being a 10...blend the text and get rid of what looks like scan lines on the render.
^^ I don't know if you personally made that or not. It's quite a jump in skill from the sigs you have on display within those links.. Anyways, good coloring, I like the brightness/contrast, it sure brings out supermans cool beams.. 7/10 Note: There are two sigs here.
Rating only top 2 left to right 5/10 and 5/10...on left too much contrast and right too blended render text sucks too lol but keep trying
its always the text and the blending of the render that gets me 1.) 7/10 background is plain lookin 2.) 9/10 looks pretty good