Rate The Sig Above You ..

i like it good depth nice bg and lovin that test and the ring around it, 8/10

just rate this one and its my first sig in photoshop (i do have little experince )

 

cool render but the bg seems a little dark and the text seems a bit plain 6.5/10

 

7/10 - nice bg, but render doesn't flow with it.

 

Impressive for defaults,gj 7/10 for both

 

The first ones text is hard to read, but i like everything else 8/10
the second on i really don't like that symbloe/text thing 6/10
third the text needs improvment, not much tho, and the render seems to dissapear in places and makes it look kinda weird to me, 7/10

cool man keep it up.

 

Too bright, bg's are blurry, renders are also bright. Text needs work. Too Big

4/10

 

9/10 and 7/10 good sigs.

 

1. 6/10 text need work
2. 7/10 text need work
3. 5.5/10 dislike those blue lines
4. 9/10 learn from that sig

 

1. Looks great but dont like the scanlines to the right they dont fit. 7/10
2. It's just to plain looking for my taste 6/10
3. same thing as 2 6/10
4. Great render and I like the brushing only thing is minor text problems but I like it 8/10

 

Yours are pretty good, but could use some improvement. I don't feel the last one utilized the colors of that great render. The first and second are slightly monotone, and the blurring on the first is... eew. Still, they're nice.

7/10s for all.

Please rate this one...

 

your current
is to me not good..sorry 4.5/10

the one you want me to rate its jsut great 7.5/10

 

Rayne

Top left, bg is missing something, and a little to much white.
7/10

Top Right, i like the simple look but text needs work, the pixel font looks like crap.
8/10

Bottom left, nice simple look but the hair on the right looks weird how its blended.
8/10

Bottom right, dont think the render fits to well
7/10

 

Look great man.. 9,5/10 really like the text..
Wel don't really like this oe.. bit plain and all the same colour.. don't like it, 7/10

 

both are very monotone. the one on the right i skind of hard to actually see the render. the bgs look great tho.. 6.5/10 for both

 

I don´t like the Text on either. The First One I like Best... Rating:
1. 7/10
2. 5/10