since no one rated marines i will, both are easily nines, maybe 10, top one if f'n amazing. noremac i like yours too, bottom one is a little bit too monochromatic for my tastes, but still good. improve your text and i'd give you a 9 for the top one
scottpie Top, i like the effect, i think its filters only and if so its pretty simple filters but i love the look. I like the cirlces to. 8/10 Bottom, not as great, not liking the colors or render, text is amazing 6/10
Marine: Top: A little dark but still very good brushing and colors 8.5 / 10 Bottom: Think bottom is very good especialy the bg 10/10
I love the top, everything flows, text works too. 8/10 maybe 9/10 Bottom isnt as impressive, work more with the top style 6/10
1st - 8/10 2nd 9.5/10 3rd 10/10 I like them all just the 1st 1 I dunno its not as good as the others I think
1st-its a little dark 8/10 2nd-there is a big black spot in the middle 7.5/10 3rd-everything fits 9.5/10