Rate The Sig Above You ..

they are too plain but i love the effects on the text

 

I love them all, espically the lighting 9/10

 

text needs work...BG is weird..the coloring is weird
7.5/10

 

I really like the one of Ryu; the lighting and coloring is perfect. No less than a 9/10.

 

1st - Eh, not my style, but I can see a lot of effort was put into it...7/10
2nd - Very nice, 9.5/10! Everything's good, just it's been done before...

 

the text on the bottom one is place bad..the manip itself is okay 8/10

the top one..text needs work...render is a bit hard to c... 7.5/10

 

9/10 for all
Rate this:

 

I like the BG and the render. Not feelin' the text though. 8/10

 

Very unique. I like the coloring.

8/10

Note: I hope nobody actually thinks I want my userbars and spinners rated...

 

I would say pretty good job. 8/10

But, for all of those smaller pictures, you could make them all 1 animated .gif to save somewhat of a headache for someone on 56k. Plus, it could look alot more neat.

 

both are similar in style, tho different colors and one has a render.
too plain imo. texts need work, and render in the 2nd needs blending. bg could do with more colors and depth too.

Sorry if I'm a little too critical, but with more experience, you'll get better

6/10 for both

 

top one render a bit over blended nice colors 7/10

bottom one like the panda an the text 8.5/10

 

you current....well there is a lot of empty space on the sig...and the render is a little dark...you could always try making the sig a little smaller. Just my thoughts...or maybe make the font larger..i dunno...5/10

your latest...um i love the green, but the render fades away, since the render is the focus, you should pull him forward all the way, and the bg has too much busy ness going on....lol...i made a word...well the bg is a back ground and should be treated as such...and the font is a little pixie and hard to read....7.5/10

Okay i know it is from a game...but its my first sig i wanna display just to get into the game...then ill start drawing game renders...and i do all mine in paint...ms paint LOL...rock on paint artist.

~Eladamri

 

7/10 render is low quality and there is no depth
Rate these:

 

holy ----, im sorry im breaking the rules, but i just have to say, thats amazing, u did all that in ms paint, thats damn amazing kudos to u my talented friend, even if it were done it photoshop it still looks pretty cool

i love ur style eldamri

blounder: pretty cool for the first 7/10

for the second im not likin the text its a bit funky 6/10