You didnt, and dont spam the section plz. Try adding more colors, work on your text, blend the render a little more, and try to get the colors to match the render or vice versa. read up on some tuts, they really can help. Based on ur post count i would say its ur first sig, or close to it? If so then, 7/10 BTW, try using more than 1 brush, and only put a few brushes on each layer.
1st - kinda boring color and text doesn't seem to match, but nice brushing 7.5/10 2nd - nice colors, and brushing, also like what you did with the text 9/10
Ive already rated ur bottom 2 b4. The halo one totally kicks ass. Your top one: Nice brushing, but i hate anime. Text is nice, btw which filter did you use for the effect on ur name? I h8 anime, but: 8.5/10
Extol i tried telling u this in another topic but i said it like ---- so here it is in a more clear way. Try lowering the opacity or changing the color on the stroke for your name in ur top sig. Now, for Fable: Pixel Stretch - not a fan of them Brushing - Not the best brushing in the world but it works for the sig. Render - Nice placement, i like how it looks in the sig. Text - It looks good, but it could be better if you made it stand out a little less, or made the colors match the colors a little more. Overall - 8/10
first one the tigers are blended very well but way to plain background 7/10 secend one blended very well its good sept text really itsnt good and try useing something besides orange.
Top Left: Little if no color. Brushing seems ok, Text is nice. Render fits, but add color. Bottom Left: I like the effect but just not the sig overall, render is a dif color than the bg, the bg seems boring. Text needs work. See what you can do with it either on the right or some place we dont expect it. Top Right: Love the sig, nice work with everything except the text. Work with ur text to make it fit, i dont like the red u put in the text and the white doesnt really fit either. Mess with that Bottom Right: It looks smooth. Text works, but isnt amazing. Render itselt doesnt really fit the bg but it works. Nice brushing. T.L - 6/10 B.L - 5/10 T.R - 8.5/10 B.R - 7/10
-MMMarine 1st = looks good but a bit monotone 7.5/10 2nd = the render seems to be too dark other than that its all ok and I like the txt 8/10
Im really tired of that comment. I couldnt do nething that looked good w/ the colors because the render was in black and white. Now... Current: Nice effects, i like the whole look. Text is good, i just dont like the HV on his blade(?) altho u made the text match perfectly, it just looks out of place. 8.5/10 Newest: I really like the lightning effect u used. Nice style it really flows. 8.5/10
for "Marine" #1) The brushing dosnt go along with the render to well and neither does the text. Needs more color. 7/10 #2) Pretty sweet. The render look alittle choppy on the hair but other than that its very nice. The name is well fit into the... sword? I guess.. haha. I like it! 9/10. Keep up the good work! -Kakor
1st = looks nice the only thing that looks bad is the kakor txt 7/10 2nd = bg is knida plaing and render needs more blending also I really don't like te txt 6/10
1st) i love the Wolverine Stock blends nicly with the rest of your image. 2nd) I love FMA, the entire sig is just..wow!