1st = very nice render and the txt is nice and so as the bg 8.5/10 2nd = nide render and blending and good bg txt just don't really fit the sig but its nice though 8/10
take out the animation, make it smaller, colors need work, text needs work, brushing isnt too well done, but keep at it mate.
top one is a bit too bright and im not feeling the text, contrast is also bad, 6/10 i ----in love it 10/10