first one looks like samus has a water gun lol, but its a decent effect. bg isn't too hot and neither is the text. 6.5/10 2nd one not really feeling at all, dislike the bg, tech brushing and text. 6/10
well both the sigs are good but the 1st one is bettter than the second fits one 8/10 the second one is 7.5/10
bg doesn't fit the render and i dont think the text fits there..7/10 second bg and colors match render perfect 9/10
The ring thing is getting so whored. It's good to learn from the pros, but it's better to add some of your own variations to differentiate. Be creative, though I'm not succeeding in that myself. Both still look good though. The renders could be better blended. 8/10 for both. I talk too much =x
8.7/10 on both, ive always liked em, and the only tuts ive read have been the rings, from mancer. heh...
first one: i like the BG and the blast, but i've seem that render 12 times today... 8/10 Second one: Pandas=Pwn; Pandas with katanas on an awesome sig= Pwnage 10/10