1st one is awsome 10/10 2nd one is nice but i dont really like the render on it and not really my style 7.5/10
first one - 6/10 bad quality render i think and it doesn't match the bg at all and txt needs work second one - a little to white and plain, txt also needs work here too 6.5/10 =/
looks too bright in some spots to me, still nice. 8.5/10. go easy on me, im still a newbie to this stuff.
pretty good bg and coloring, text needs a little work and the render is blended in a bit too much, still pretty good 7/10, gj