top i would give a 4-10, bg+colors bad.... bottom-8-10, i like it, good bg, good render, text is alright
oooh both very grungy the first one is great, even the text works 9/10 the second one is really good as well, though there is something about it, that i dont like. Sorry... wish I could place it... 8/10
Dinges, im so in love with your top sig The sig is good, but the girl/render omg, im in love with HER!!!! everytime i see ur sig i stop what im doing for a moment to enjoy (damm i sound like a perv ) anyway, other than being byast (spelling?) to the girl, the sig is really good nice brushing, very good use of colors and nice bg 10/10 for the top one i cant remember what the other one looks like sorry (if possible id like to obtain the render, ill cred ya and wont really use it)
ive been flicking through ur sigs and the only one that was really nice was the chaos theory one, some where choppy some needed more blending and some needed better text 5/10 average and the scct one got an 8
yeah it was one of my first sigs lol. well anyway i dont like the border and the size (more a banner ) but the background is nice, and the render funny 7.5/10