Ok fine here. 2 There are quite a few things that are bringing this tag down. First off I can not tell if you did or not, but it looks like you did a layer blurred and set on lighten. That never looks good in my opinion and most experienced tags makers. The effecst are very minimal in the front of the tag, therefore, making it seem almost like you made a background and slapped a render on it. The background itself has not the best effects either and is very monotone and could use quite a few more darker areas. The overall tag has no flow and no depth at all which is what usually makes a good tag. Also some of the effects in the tag seem to be oversharpened. There is no really good light source pertaining to the render and the light/dark transition on the left is not the best. Also the text to me just does not fit in and the square thing looks random imo. 2 This tag, the first thing I thought to myself was it was WAY too bright. Also the tag is very monotone. I do not think you should have put the color of the render and maybe should have stuck to colors that more complimented the render. Again there are minimal effects. Correct me if I am wrong, but it looks like mostly what you did was have a background with a couple c4d renders and a mario render. The overall tag has no real depth to it and could use some darker areas. Also there is no really good flow in the tag. It looks like it was attempted but the effects on the left ruined that. The text also just looks like it was put in there to have your name on the tag. Text is a very important part of any tag if you so choose to put it in. Also the render itself in a few areas looks of bad quality with this tag. Also for me, the border looks uneccesary. There you go, now please do not complain about this again nor tell me to grow up.
5-6 Mainly because the background is a bit plain around the sides and the lighting seems a bit too strong. (If wanting more CnC you are welcome to post in my thread - link located in signature)
First off all, beateful stock. Second, great effects, I like the messy things going on in there, lovely whilr, the only thing that isnt that good is the text, wich I know you could do sooo much better, well its an 8/10. Good job mate.
They all look good, but my favourite is the middle one. Great blending all the way, solid colors, great text and sweet render. 9/10 for that one.
7 - nice lighting effects and bg, but the lighting on the chief I don't like, especially on the visor. 6 - decent effecs, text needs work, sig is a bit plain overall.
