that first one was a tut, i just dident have a new enough photoshop 7.5/10^ new one i just finished making
6/10 for first, oversaturated with color/bit blurry 5/10 for second, kinda plain, just brushing imo..
5/10 needs better lighting and coloring 5.5/10 to simple for my tate and could also use better lighting rate this plus otheres
5- Tooooo random and needs more BG 4- Not appealing. At all. But that's just me 6- Decent Effects 8- Nicely put together