Heh, well, to tell you the truth, I don't really like the first one. It just gives off a smudgey appearance. The second one however, is amazing! I love it. For your first use of a stock, it's astounding. I give it a 9/10 for sure. EDIT! Oops, I rated Mez. Oh well, to continue. Clown, I really like the work on the second one, but the first one looks good as well. 7/10 on the first and 8.5/10 on the second. :3
IMO I prefere the first, it seems more simple. the second seems too complex and is too bright but its probably cos im tired >.< Edit~ I deleted my other one - Doh haha I wasnt sure who you rated
7/10 Dont really like the texture on this one, or the lightsource 9/10 Texture works well with this one nice Job 8/10 I love the effects but the Red and blue bars kill it for me
I'm not such a big fan of sprite sigs, but I won't let that determine your rating. Out of all the sprite sigs I've seen, that second one has got to be one of the best. I give the first one a 7/10, and the second a 9/10. I really like the effects around his feet in the second one.
InfernoSnow---- I would give it a 7 out of 10. Mainly becuase it looks kinda flat to me. And there is too much ripple or wave in it.