Rate The Sig Above You ..

Cant see it
4

 

8.75 for both real nice job, but in the 2nd why couldn't that be 2 girls

 

EDIT:Was too slow
9/10
10/10

I really like them

 

Well, since I'm your friend IRL, and can't really give you a straight answer, I'm going to tell you based on my feelings towards them, not "/10".

I really like the background in the top one, but I have to say... It doesn't go with the render. You should change the render to something a little; how to say this: "Cooler".

I've already told you I really like the Kratos sig for some reason. I don't know, I just really like it. Especially the secondary, red Kratos.

For the popout, I don't really know about the render quality. I know you're still practicing at blending, and that's good. I really like the metallic text and that font (Mael), but I don't know if the color and texture go with the feel of the sig. I also really like the simplicity and, well, "sandy-ness" of the background.

Bite down on that post. xD

 

3.5
3

 

Reasoning would help a lot. I'm fine with your rating, but I would like to know why so I can improve upon it.

7
8

For the first one, I like abstract, but I think this might be overdoing it a little. For me personally; everyone has their own style and likes, so I leave the judgement of your own work up to you.

I like the effect of the second one and the simple colors. I've used the whole mirror-like effect before myself and it always turns out as something I'm proud to display.

 

I just dont like brushed sigs, they are old and very out of style. Not liking the colors, the typo, and the lighting could use work.

3.5
3

 

9/10
8/10 Not feelin the reflection...

 

7/10
maybe add abit more color and lighting.

 

All of your signatures are crazy! They're awesome. Deffinitely keep up the great work; I just really like them all. :3

 

thanks
6/10 for both
work on bg.

 

8
7
6

 

10
6
7
8.75

Sweet images!

 

2/10 blend thge render, looks terrible imo

 

4.5/10 Quite plain