If your new they're pretty good ( i wont give rate), on the 1st one: Work on render blending and text. Also,try to create some kind of flow. The 2nd has some good effects but it has some too bright effects, and it's a bit monotone. Keep it up!
If you made it from scratch, I assume you did as your a great designer, then Id have to say 10/10 Really loving the grayscale, they own Text is the only thinbg that could be improved IMO but thats just me being picky, as I would like to give some sort of Critiscism Excellent
Did you even look at the sig? Check the right side and all that.......... anyhoo............. Love your style mate, just maybe need to add some flow to them. I like your sprite the best. about 8 for them all
thanks 9/10 nice style it looks like you didnt do much but i know you did nice colors and flow and use of effects keep it up.
hehe every one has their own style 9/10 for both loving the effects and feel of the tag keep it up man.
hotrocks I like it but, it just seems alittle lain. I really like wht youve done, i just feel it could have abit more too it 8/10