Meh 5/10 I dont like c4d, ive seen that a million times before. If you must use c4d, be creative with it
7/10 6/10 7.5/10 -> this one is nice! Gj Blending and (color) flow could be better. Text and borders aren't a must.
6/10 - not much done with the bg, plus I've seen that style a lot 8/10 - I like the "wings" and the text is nice. again, not much in the bg, but works better with that sig nice work