Rate The Sig Above You ..

7/10 - The eyes... Not a huge fan, Background is lovely though ^_^
8/10 - Great Idea, decent execution

 

good lighting. prefer text. 9/10.

good flow. once again good lighting. just not my personal pref
9/10

 

I can see the concept you went with on the first one, but Im not really likeing it. 7/10

Second one is kind of boring for me, still looks nice regardless. 7.5/10

 

4.5/10
Which sig should i replace this with?

 

the first one. shows you have 2 completely diffferent styles.

rating the monalesa (or however you spell it)
creativeness is a +. good effect.
8.5/10

 

7/10
6/10

 

4
8

 

I dont like the first one, it simply doesnt look good to be. Second is much nicer 7/10.

 

first 7/10
second 9/10...just not feelin the text

 

monotone, but no issues with that. nice work.9/10

big small :-/
ripple on text? could be better.
7/10

 

first one looks too busy, and just slapping on white text wont work...

6/10

the second one is better

7/10

 

both of these 7-7.5

should i replace electra with this

 

I dont think so, your electra sig is better than that one. 7/110

 

8 very nice
7

 

Hmm 5/10, just 2 renders onde a cheasy background