7/10 for the first. Backround seems to simple, and that red at the bottom stands out quite a bit. Can't read the font AT ALL. 7.5/10 for the second, I don't really like the colors, or how the bg blends with the render.
7/10 took me a while to recognize kain. the background is like... messy. the text is good. not feeling the border.
8.5/10 for the first 8/10 on the second You have a unique style that I like alot. I am still pretty new and this is one of my first sigs that I have made with no tut(referring to the Samus sig.)I still need to get better at text.