Top: 8/10 I love the flow and effect Bottom: 6/10 bg is a okay but I like the text though Keep up the good work!
not including the macjeff.net one lol cause it's not exactly a sig 1st : Pretty well done, the colors fit the character, background is well done also, text blends well 8/10 2nd : Seems better, love the stock, text blends really well, bg is aite... 9/10 i'd say 8.5/10 , cause it's somewhere in the middle LOL
^_^ Looks like you just started making sigs, text is a bit hard to read and it looks too rough and overlayed, 7/10 for effort 5/10 for acual sig ;\