Rate The Sig Above You ..

i understand that you are a beginner so:
7/10
bg is too dark, border is bad text needs effect and i don't like outer glow on render

 

I actually like those sigs, good job. 9/10

 

Nice Ichigo one 8/10
Nice colours on the robot thingy 7/10

 

Not liking the Border and BG is a bit dark add a motion blur to the line as well 6/10

 

don't reall like the filters only sig.. not liking the background in second sig you nee dto work on text..

1ste: 6,5/10
2nd: 7/10

 

Yea those are good, you can see the render a little to much though

 

dont like the top one too much, you cant make anything out... 7/10


bottom one is nice 8/10

 

2nd sig r0x ! 10/10

 

second that, i love it.

okok, this is something i came up with, i know i suck at photoshop, but please rate it, and give me some advise of what tutorials to buy because i really want to get better at this.

edit: lol forgot signature

 

My uncle liked Blink 182 so I'll give it 8/10

 

8/10, everythings good i just dont like the yellow bar a whole lot

 

Both look good, no real complaints.. 8/10 Both

 

rate and advise please

paranoia, yours looks good, but not my style 7/10

 

i really like the effect, but its a bit dark....7/10

 

Ok work, just work on the text a bit more. 7/10