Both are very good. Nice angel feel to it. Hmm, maybe a - point would go to your 2nd, I see some faint ripple-thingy-mark in the lower portion of the bg. Anyways, GJ! 9/10 8.8/10
7/10 theres too much text crowded together 7.5/10 i dont like the bg behind the guy but otherwise theyre both pretty good sigs