5/10 bg needs more depth and better colors. Render needs better blending and text needs better size, color and blending
6/10 The sticking out part ruins it and its not transparent or anything.. 7.5/10 Work ton th e text and get some open space filled.
Top one 7/10 , I just dont see the text working its magic there. Second same. I just think the render is overused. (sorry) 3rd I like it 8/10 text needa a littlw work in that one. Overall: 7.5/10
Sig: Something about the border bothers me, dunno why...>>; render blends in well, great brushing, but the text has too much of a glow effect, imo. Overall, 8/10.