6.5/10. the bg is really plain and sucked of life, basically just a polar coordinate with some brushing.
Top two very similar 7/10 Love the uniqueness of third down, but animation could be made sweeter, still love it though 8/10
I like the colors, yellow isn't used much as a base color. You brought the darkness in just right. Overall, I love it. 9/10 I'm making 2 new sigs right now, so no worries it'll be the last time you rate my super old ones