ooooo....... 1st= Im not sure about the bg and the 'render', they kinda clash, but I like the bg.......6/10 2nd= render is nicely blended........the blend from colour to colour could be better, but good try....not sure about the bg colours, but they're not too bad........7/10 Mines a vector.....
Don't use luminosity on the renders. First has to big text, it's monotone and the bg could be better. Second is to big overall and pretty much has the same faults as the first one, can't really see the text. Keep trying tho Rates: 3,7 - 2,8.
1 looks good I like text but render and bg looks nice 7/10 2 this sig looks great I love you bg and text is very good 8,5/10
1st 8.5/10 .. really nice colors and flashes .. really like the effect ! 2nd 7.5/10 .. its a bit strange but still verry nice .. keep up the good work ! ^_^