Rate The Sig Above You ..

k i will complete the last rate

1st i dont found the render shape, but bg its good

and maybe some work in text

2nd text needs work, and bg 2, and maybe blending the render

 

wat u think of rating like this??

rating:
bg 5
text 4
render usag 2
overall 4
------------------

5+4+2+4=15
15/4= 3.75

thats an example (random example)

 

3/10 for first, i hate popouts and text needs work
4/10 for second, better but everything still needs work
honestly i dont think you can say anything about anyone's text

 

8/10 for both, they are the most whored style around.

 

honestly

i think that u cant said nothing about no1 sigs

 

nobody has a perfect sig my friend and i rate yor a 7.5/10.

colors dont go well

 

those are sweet i would love a tut on both.... 10/10 for both

 

I dunno if I wanna put myself up to this but ...

I'd say 9/10 for both of yours, Nice colors, but having Ghost partly cut off kinda ruins it

*This is for ghost - not caboose*

 

a tut! i might make one after getting so many requests.

1st - 6/10 yawn, sorry but true.
2nd - 7.5/10 pretty good

 

both look prettty original. i dont really see the top one.. but the bottom one is very original. top: 7.8/10

bottom: 9/10

 

5/10 all.....they are too dark and i dont like the text

 

pretty good for both.. bottom is a little too contrasty, well looks lik,e it is
7.5/10 for both

 

6/10 text could use some work and it seems a little empty

 

7/10 dont really mind the renders

 

1st - 7/10
2nd - 5/10
3rd - 8/10