Not bad! 7.5/10 the opacity of the text is too low and this bg isnt my cup of tea ! I dont know why!! Double D
I like your lower sig loads, I like everything about it, [9/10] but in the top one i give like 6 or 7 because I just think the text and the charachters face the outlines too sharp, and I also think that the text is too standard.
well ur top one is seriously outclassed by ur 2nd sig lol 1st 6/10 bad text bad render 2nd 9.9/10 Vnice render very good light effect