Nice render in the first one but not to crazy about the background(6/10). The second one is your best, luv the brushing within it.(8/10)
lol if u mean the top one, its all photoshop defaults (except the stars ) Love ur one, good feel to it 8/10
#1: 7/10: just a bit too plain but it still looks great #2: 9/10: really feelin it man very nice job with the sparks!
1st one: 7/10, dont like the lighting on the render too much 2nd one: 10/10, i find the render hard to incorperate easily enough, very nice, awesome boarder