Rape Me.

I'm a noob when it comes to graphics, theres alot to learn. However, I have made a few sigs I would like to get rated.






I am looking for some real critiques.

Would you consider these to be decent. Or should, I give up all hope, because I am never going to get it.

Thanks. I have learned alot from this community, the tutorials have been great and, obviously the renders are incredible.

 

its not a bad start for some one new to PS but your 1st sig is your best it has some creativity to it good work

 

They aren't as bad as you're making them out to be really. The first one is pretty neat, as is the third. I think I know what you were trying to do with the second, but I don't think it looks very good.

All in all though, they aren't too bad. You should see some of my early work. *shudder*

 

The 1st signature, I'm ish on the motion blur effect. The background is great, but the text effect...ehh, could have without. I'd give that one a:

7/10

The 2nd signature is great. That would get a:

8/10

And the 3rd siggy, I love the render, and background. Done nicely with better effects. That gets a:

8/10

And that's all, you're getting better.

 

First off, dont save as .gif

Im really lazy so il just bullet point some things that need work

dont use that border

add more to BG

Work on text

Spend loads of time on oyur sigs

meh................

 

why?


Thanks everyone. You should have seen my first attempts at sigs... consisted of merely script-fu text. Lame.

 

.gif files tend to be of lower quality than say, .png files.

As for the border, I assume he thinks it sticks out too much, or just doesn't look good, though I don't know for sure.

 

not bad for a first go round, i liek the ironman sig it looks nifty.. but yea don't save as a gif.. jpg or png all the way.. keep it up the m8

 

In photoshop when you "save for web" it defaults to .gif

I guess I assumed to preserve the color spectrum I had to.

Thanks for the heads up.

Anyone have any advice or know of any good tuts or border variations?

 

1)blend in the render a bit, other then that its good.
2)blend in the render, add something to it.
3)ewwww..renders to small, not blended.
but good try, keep it up.

 

Very nice sigs good renders use my fav is the last one good man.

 

Nice work.

 

Some are a bit too blurry. Otherwise fine.

 

They are. Ok?
the second one is the best i think, nice BG but the girl is smushed and you need text help!

 

Excellent, thanks for the advice everyone.

Yes text is more aggravating than anything else