Pt Submission #10

http://www.gamerenders.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=149330

I think its pretty good. Its well explained and the outcome is pretty good IMO.

Im gonna say Yes.

 

Voted no.

The tutorial itself is good but it isn't well explained and there is horrible grammar throughout it.

 

hard choice, i couldnt find any of the horrible grammar that Ren found tho... so urrmm, im gonna vote no, as there was little depth into how he did it, i.e. the color balance part. some steps will be quite confusing to the newer photoshop users as well. nice result, but uhh, no

 

he doesnt describe the smudging very well. and its the base of his whole sig.
some vital parts lack some explanation.

i vote no to.

 

To be honest, its like a half assed attempt at a tutorial, as if he just did it for extra credz or reps...

 

I dont care how god or how popular that was, my vote is a definate No.

---- Grammer, tut took him like 5 mins to make.

 

I vote no. Just something about it that makes me say no..

 

Currently, the "no" is impossible to be outvoted.

Final Result: No.