O F F I C I A L || Application Discussion Thread

<div align="center">Applicant's Name</span></span>

Negatives: -Comments-

Positives: -Comments-

Final Decision: Yes / <span style="color:#FF0000">No[/b][/quote]

Code:

[size="4"][b]Applicant's Name[/b][/size]

[b]Negatives:[/b] -Comments-

[b]Positives:[/b]  -Comments-

[b]Final Decision: Yes [/b]/[b] No[/b]

 

Applicant: Tub-A-Wub

Original Application: http://www.gamerenders.com/forum/index.php...t&p=4242225

 

I made a thread but then I forgot about it and Deleted it lastly
Anyhow

Current Applicant is: Tub A Wub

Please Post your comments about him below

-Zain

You beat me

 

Tub A Wub

Negatives:Tags all have similar perspectives. They aren't very original; smudge liquify and it's done. Some are pretty simple to the point where it appears as if little work was done. Similar effects. Some lack a clear focal. Typography isn't varied either. Some LP's are kinda bad.

Positives: Kanye West tag is nice. One LP is actually not bad, hopefully it's his LP. >_>

Final Decision: No Reason being his tags need to be a lot more varied, he has to try different styles and perspectives.

 

Negatives: Liquify is ho'd in most of his tags. Black and white tags need better contrast. Text needs to be varied. Colours are poor except for the first.

Positives: Very nice colours in first, cool tag. First LP is awesome.

Final Decision: No Needs more variation in compo and styles, techniques etc.

 

TubAWub

Negatives:
The text used on his tags all pretty much have a bold look and it kinda sticks out from the focal. Liquify seems to be used a bit in his tags too, and also the coloring is almost around the same in each apart from the 1st one which is nice.

Positives:
Nice first tag and an ok LP(last one), but hes an active member on GR.

Final Decision: No TAW needs to work on his text and coloring and also needs more variation between styles.

 

Even though most of you disagree, I have a different opinion

Positives: He has his own style. His tags and Large Pieces Portray what he is trying to tell us in that Art Piece. His LP's are good as they show different scenarios on which we all can work on. Especially this one: This. Overall Tub A Wub's Tags do seem a little bit over used but, he takes my mind off in most of them. He has variety of different tags, and I disagree with everyone who posted before me in that area <_<
Example:






Negatives: Like I said above his tags show a bit over used of the same method, but if you look in his Photobucket he has more to offer than just those. His variety is huge. I dislike the use of same text in all of the tags, but then again, none of us are perfect in anything, especially text

Final Decision: Yes from me.


Z

 

TubAWub

Negatives: The liquifying is redundant.. There needs to be more variation in style overall. Colours are quite boring except for the first and maybe the third, bar her face being red >.< Change the damn font

Positives: The tags are quite neat and lucid.. The LPs look great. I want me a pair of those shoes

Final Decision: Yes I just like the feel of the tags.. They're so powerful in a certain way.

 

TubaWub

Negatives: Liquify is a little overused, but nothing too redundant. Text needs to vary, although his current style does work for him. A few of his tags lack depth and proper contrast.

Positives: I like that he is able to take his creativity, transform it, and portray it within his tags. He has a great ability to have a wild style, but other tags are near-realism, and it takes some talent to be able to do that. He has more than a few LP's, which is always a good thing for AG, as we all know.

Final Decision: Yes

 

Guys just on the point of varying styles, its kinda redundant if you can't pull it off tbh, and I find the execution on most of the fx a bit messy. He also has some floating head render disease, and 3/5 zain posted are mono. Just adding to my point.

 

3 No
3 Yes

I'm about to go out to dinner with the family (20 friggen people) so until I get back, more opinions are allowed. I'll make a final decision tonight.

 

Zain, that's the same LP I was talking about, and I don't think it's his for some reason.

Correction: It's definately NOT his. "The Dopeshow" is made by *NKeo

 

Decision: Accepted</span>

 

So he ripped? Or people need to change their decision?

 

Wait..did he rip :huh: