Next-gen Vs. Irrelevant

Next-Generation:



Irrel:


first to 10 no creds

 

Gonna have to go for Next-Gen, although you need to blend the render a bit.
I love the background on it.
1-0 NG

 

IREELLLLLLLL all the way ><
love that sig the design the colors wonderfull

1-1

 

IREEL gmv much better the colors are great and the text is perfect great sig

 

3-1, Irrel
because next-gen got to big sig for me.
but he got a great background, but to big
so my vote got Irrel

 

irrel gmv..

next gen's sig is nice too. but irrel's has an interesting style and design.. appealing

 

Voting Next-Gen. I swear, this is one of the best sigs I've ever seen. Do NOT blend the render, puh-lease. Foreground and background are perfect, render is well positioned, typography is something to be admired. Seriously, I'm voting for this one hardcore.

Next-Gen, I'll give you 20 creds for Learning Rights. Yes, I'm serious. You want?

 

if you stick to this logic, then untill the end of time you will remain a noob.

 

Next-gen GMV.

Nice colors and the background is just amazing.

 

Although it as a little to big i i go with Next Gen. just great gackground and flows well.

 

Next-gen, the size is the only thing i hate about it.

 

Next gen definatly, because of the work in the bg

 

Irrel GMV
His tag has blending, colors, texture and a bit of depth.
And the background flows. ^ _^

 

Not at all. It's simply the tought that there is no rule that applies to every piece of art, and while GFX might not always be completely original (incorporating stocks and such) it's still art to me. I really just looked at it and decided that in this particular case, I think that blending the render would lessen its feel.

There obviously aren't a lot of people who think as highly of this sig as I've decided to. However, I believe that the feel it's achieved, the one that I love, is dependant on both its size and the lack of blending, two things which have been downed upon.

So, really, I'm just stating an opinion. If this makes me a newb, well, I guess being a GFX master is like getting braindamage, isn't it?

But aaaaanyway...

5-6, Next-Gen. Gotta love close battles.

 

irrel gmv nice sig overall 6-6 tied