My Professional Opinion

I do like the texture on this piece. The image treatment is a little iffy, and there's no type.

I give it a 4/10

 

Wondering which version you prefer and any other comments you have would be cool as well.

 

Can't tell a difference. But 1/10 for both

 

Hope i can get 3/10 LOL.

 

lets giver another whirl bro

 

Don't like the composition here. Color's are festive.

Image treatment is a little wonky, and lack of type gets points off.

3/10

 

not sure I like the complete washout here. Nice composition and placement. I do like the flow you have going on here.
--

More impact in full color:


8/10

 

Seems random, nothing special, no text...all points off.

2/10

 

first sig in about 6 months:

 

Coloring - Great
Type - Great
Layout- Very Nice
Image treatment - a bit over filtered.

8/10

 

Quick one needed some feedback.

 

I like the treatment on this one. The fading is a little unnecessary on the right side.

Type placement is nice. a Little hard to find... but easter eggs are neat.

Color is a a little washed out. Not a lot of contrast here.

over all 6/10

 

thanks a lot for your feedback