The second one is very choppy and what not, and I don't think the first one would look that cool in a sig but its a WICKED good render... hehe I used an oxymoron ^.^
Magna Carta renders are always awesome. The first one is nice, but I think the sword handle is supposed to be straight. Here's what I'm talking about: The second render is good but the outlines aren't smooth.
dude man the first one is sweet, but the second one kicks some major butt, ill give u creds when i use it.