L A -384 Vs Wolverine

JUDGES MAY VOTE HERE NOW

LA-384's entree:

Original:



Rendered:



Wolverine's entree:

Please note. WOLVERINE DOES have permission to render this image. I asked BOTH creators and they agreed to it being rendered and used. If you would like proof, please PM Kazuya.

Original:

http://www.deviantart.com/view/15851076/

Rendered:

 

JUDGES MAY VOTE HERE NOW.

 

LA-384

This render is great, absolutely prem! :lol:
The hair is good, but I'd assume a better job could be done at it. The image is not choppy at all, which is absolutely a + for my judgement, and it's VERY large. It's useful for pretty much any kind of graphic you could think of. The difficulty, I'd say, would be a 9/10, the hair looks really difficult. The render, overall? I like it alot!

Wolverine
LOL isn't that interesting; I found it funny that Wolverine would be doing a render of Wolverine. (huh? lol)
It's a very good cut, but it looks very simple, too; the difficulty looks to be around 6/10. I really like the attention to the details in this render, such as the hair on Wolverine's arm, and the... saliva.... :lol: It is choppy in some places, however. The usefullness of this image would span across web graphics and signatures, but is much too small to be useful in any kind of wallpaper. Good job!

This was a tough decision, but in the end I chose LA-384. Congratulations! ^_^

Happy New Year!

~nightfire

 

COMON GUYS WE NEED MORE VOTES!!!

 

LA-384's entree:

it looks like a medium to hard difficulty cut render !! its very well cut very clean and all !! great size very usable !!

Wolverine's entree:
that for me is a hard difficulty render !! nice size !! very very clean nice cut !! very usable !!

i vote for
Wolverine

 

LA-384: First of all I must say that the hair must have been a :censored:
Its not all that original or unique because now FF is just whored its all I see now. Its a clean cut. Not to mention useable seeing all the sigs with Rikku.

Wolverine: Thats umm...nice. Well I give you points for originalltiy but its not to difficult.I'm pretty sure its useable.

my vote goes to LA-384 because its useable and and more difficuly than Wolverines.

Edit: FINALLY FINISHED ALL THE JUDGING!!!

 

Both renders are well cut

LA-384 : your render is very large, good quality and very usable

Wolverine : the render size is not huge but it is still good enough for a sig. The render is deffinitly unique although im not too sure how usable it would be in a sig or banner

LA-384 gets my vote because i feel his render is well cut and of a good size and quality that would allow it to be used in a varitey of graphics

 

LA-384's is not showing for me. Even tried using show picture after. User posted image is all I get.

*edit... Ok, thanks for sending it to me in pm LA-384... I'm sorry but the hair is just killing me, makes it extremely hard to use in any sigs that aren't really light colors. Other than that it's a nice job, but been done many times.

As for Wolverine, Great pic... the hair's on the arm are a bit choppy though. Will analyze further once LA-384's is posted also. The rest is quite smooth and very usable in sigs.

Therefore, Wolverine GMV.

 

LA-384:

Nice render, but It's been done so many times before, so I find it boring. There's also 'sky' in the hair (Blue parts). I don't find it good in signature's.. Don't know why, just doesn't works for me. Overall, nice job.

Wolverine:
Now this is something I haven't seen before. It's extremly detailed, wich is a big + in my book. The render is also original, maybe not too hard to make, but it's still a good render.

Hard choice, but in the end, Wolverine gmv

 

3 - 2 To LA so far!

LA's image has been re-hosted!

 

I've edited my post with my vote. Thanks for re-hosting.

 

Thanks for your vote 4nub1s ^_^

3 - 3 - We have a tie so far!

 

LA-384 GMV. The render was much harder, bigger, and annoying to cut. Its definatly professionaly cut.

 

LA-384:

Positive:
- Decent size and taken time on rendering
- Premium cut BESIDES the hair

Negative:
- Hair poorly cut [I know its hard but still ]
- Done quite frequently so not unique but still quite useable

Wolverine:

Positive:
- Render quite unique - havent seen it before
- Prem cut
- Found it funny

Negative:
- Quite small
- Useable slightly but in jokey way

My vote goes to ... LA-384

It was a very difficult decision - Its either was uniqueness of Wolverine's or the size and usable render of LA-384 - But went for LA's

5-3 to LA-384

 

5 - 3 To LA.

3 More votes will declare him the winner!