Kroga Vs. Psychospike

Winners Bracket

Renders will be judged on:
Difficulty
How unique the render is
Usability - IS A MAJOR FACTOR!!
How Well The Image Has Been Cut
Size - NOTE This Is Not A Major Factor.

Kroga:

Original

http://www.soulchamber.us/uploads/d15de6d477.jpg

Rendered



Psychospike:

Original:

http://img422.imageshack.us/img422/7273/originalpng3zm.png

Rendered:

 

Judges may vote here now!

 

These are great renders

Kroga

Your render actually appears to be quite difficult, around 8/10. I like the render alot, the way the hair was done was nice but the way it was all sliced up was very poor if I may say so. It appears to be nice for signatures and web graphics, moreso with web graphics. However this render is excellent for wallpapers, something that's quite uncommon . Overall it's a good cut

Psychospike

Nice job on this render, it's done very well with the curves but the blocky appearance of the stun-baton (or whatever it is ) is strange. Great cut though and nice for signatures and web graphics, and although it's a little small it cannot be used for wallpapers very efficiently. The cut doesn't appear to look too difficult, around 6/10 or so, but it was done nicely. Good job!

My vote goes to

*drum roll*

Psychospike

It was a really tough decision despite the cut-up hair of Kroga's, which was the ultimate factor in the end. Psychospike, you did a wonderful job! Good work everyone!

~nightfire

 

Well i noticed the original picture didn't show up anymore...
So here:

 

People, WE NEED MORE VOTES

 

Kazuya, I think we need new voters if the voters aren't going to be active and vote...

 

both are good renders...

RENDER A....KROGA
although slightly choppy in some places and the gaps in the hair are a bit of a problem the render is quite usable and at a glance seem to be quiet difficult...

RENDER B.....Psychospike
nice cut and again the render itself is quite useable but the difficuly level doesnt seen to be very hard also could do with been a bit bigger nice job though...

my vote goes to....
Kroga on the difficulty level alone.

 

Kroga GMV. Render was much harder to cut..I believe psychos render was about novice level at cutting. No hard parts on it, on the contrary, the white is very hard to cut through.

 

Difficulty on both renders wasnt that high. Usability; imo the 2nd render is more usable in signatures, thats why i pick

Psychospike

 

Okay its 2 each so far, just a few more votes, comon!!!!

 

Kroga: Difficulty on the render is moderate with a lot of hair to cut out. It's rendered well but the quality on the render itself is a little questionable. I can see the render easily being used in sigs.

Psychospike: Very easy render and highly useable in sigs (see this one all the time). One thing I don't like is all that feathering on the rendering -- and I don't feel that the rendering was too difficult on this one, so I give my vote to Kroga.

Kroga GMV

 

3-2 to Kroga! Comon, just a few more votes >_<

 

for kroga's i get user posted image

 

Psychospike: your render is alright but the difficulty and quality are both not good....

The size and usuability are both very low.

Kroga nice job the hair isnt awesome but its an all around good render and the difficulty isn't majore but its ok.


Kroga GMV

 

i like the second one better its well cut and it looks really cool, but it may be cuz im not into anime