Huy-n Vs. *xyz*tinx

Xexe

 

Glad to have your respect BlzrD

 

Difficulty: 7/10
Uniquness: 4/10 (has been done way way too much)
Usability: 8/10
How Well The Image Has Been Cut: 10/10
Size: 8/10


*XYZ*Tinx's render

Difficulty: 8.5/10
Uniquness: 10/10 never seen this one before
Usability: 8/10
How Well The Image Has Been Cut: 9.5/10
Size: 8.5/10

 

Huy-n:
Difficulty: 9/10 - The hair looks extremely difficult.
Uniquness: 3/10 - Been done far too much.
Usability: 10/10
How Well The Image Has Been Cut: 9.5/10 -Excellent smooth cut
Size: Perfect size.

*xyz*tinx
Difficulty: 9/10 - The BG is really complicated and difficult to see main pic.
Uniquness: 10/10 - Never seen before
Usability: 5/10 - The usability is okay, not the best quality image and i dont really think its a great scene there.
How Well The Image Has Been Cut: (Taking the BG into account) 8/10 - Some little bits of the BG still left in, in and around the render.
Size: Perfect Size.

Totals
Huy-n: 32
*xyz*tinx 32

My vote:
My vote goes to HUY-N because now that its an equal score after looking back at my vote it is still hard to decide.
I go with HUY-N because i just think it would look better in a tag. ^_^

 

I`m a little bit confused..overall Huy-N got 31.5/40 and now *XYZ*TinX got 35.9/40 and you voted for Huy-N`s render...hmm..strange..

Where`s your final vote?

 

*Fixed it.

 

im assuming "E"s vote went to XYZ since it had a score of 44.5/40 where as Huy-N's had a score of 37/50, but i guess its better to not assume...

 

I havent voted. I probly wont because this is now being run poorly.

 

Ya this is going rather oddly :huh:

 

Huy-n:

Difficulty:8/10 - The only hard part it seem's to be was the hair

Uniquness:4/10 - Been done a lot.

Usability:6/10 - Usable in sig's but wouldn't be my first choice.

How Well The Image Has Been Cut: 10/10 - I have nothing to say about this because it is perfectly cut.

Size:10/10 - The size is perfect

*XYZ*TinX:

Difficulty:9/10 - That looks REAL hard to cut out with the flowers and all.

Uniquness:10/10 - I have never ever seen it before.

Usability:6/10 - As said to Huy-n, usable but not my first choice

How Well The Image Has Been Cut:10/10 - Very nicely cut. Very clean all the way around.

Size:10/10 - Perfect Size

----

Scores:

Huy-N:38/50

*XYZ*TinX:45/50

----

My vote as to go to *XYZ*TinX

 

eh...

8-3?

 

lol i suppose so then.

 

Yes, i know that set voters are much more effective / fair but infortunatly we were just going at such a slow pace and the majority of voters weren't judging.

Sorry again and it looks like huy-n is the winner.

Will have the next table up soon and if im not mistaken the next is the final or semi - you will be given a bit longer to prepare ^_^

-Jay