Huy-n Vs. *xyz*tinx

You may now judge in the battle even if you are not on the judging list, however your vote must be detailed and un-bias.
ROTY entrants may not vote.</span>

Losers Bracket

Renders will be judged on:

Difficulty
Uniquness - How unique the render is (has it been done before)
Usability - IS A MAJOR FACTOR!!
How Well The Image Has Been Cut
Size - NOTE This Is Not A Major Factor.

Huy-N:

Original:

<a href=\'http://www.exoload.com/206/1139965893.jpg\' target=\'_blank\'>http://www.exoload.com/206/1139965893.jpg</a>

Render:

<img src=\'http://www.exoload.com/uploads/306/1143104286.png\' border=\'0\' alt=\'user posted image\' />

<span style=\'color:yellow\'>*XYZ*Tinx:

Original:

unavailable

Render:

 

Huy-N's render

Difficulty: 9/10
Uniquness: 5/10 (been done way too much)
Usability: 8/10
How Well The Image Has Been Cut: 10/10
Size: 9.5/10


*XYZ*Tinx's render

Difficulty: 8.5/10
Uniquness: 9/10
Usability: 6/10
How Well The Image Has Been Cut: 8.5/10 (a little choppy on some parts)
Size: 8.5/10

my vote goes to Huy-N

 

Huy GMV. I'm not gonna use the whole thing, because I don't have time.

Huy- Very high usability, it's a full body. It was very difficult, I have seen the original countless times, and finding ALL that hair on a dark background isn't easy. Uniqueness, seen it before... quite a lot of times. Size, HUGE.

Tinx- Pretty usable. It's nearly full body, and it would be good for coloring and such. I've seen this before, and it is quite difficult indeed, the leaves are hard to spot . Uniqueness, seen it before a few times. Size, pretty good size. It's the largest possible as far as wallpapers go, but Huy's is litterally 2x that big, so that is pretty much what did it in the end.

 

Difficulty-
Both renders are very difficult. Where Huy-N's has the hair, XYZ has the leafs. Persoanlly I cant reflect on difficulty in an accurate manner since XYZ did not present an origional, I will rate them both equally here.

Uniquness -
Huy-N's has been done numerous times before, so it is not unique at all as far as im concerned. XYZ has not been done before (i havnt seen it atleast), so it is far more unique than Huy-N. XYZ wins this portion of the judging.

Usability -
I personally could easily use Huy-N's render over XYZ's render simply for the nice, smooth flow of the darker colors. The other is heavily contrasted between colors and would be hard for me to use personally. My vote in this category goes to Huy-N.

How Well The Image Has Been Cut -
I wont even begin to compare these, as I said the other one doesnt even have a picture that it was cut from, I have no clue if it was on a white background or blended in. Personally I have seen that hair is by far harder than leafs, so Huy-N will get this vote for me.

Size -
Definately Huy-N by far, its not even a choice.

In the end I give my vote to Huy-N, despite the fact that render has been done so many times, it is the better render, he did supply the origional, it is larger, it is more usable and overall a far nicer signature.

 

OH CRAP! SORRY!





If you have already voted, please dont change your vote based on the fact that i have now encluded the original

 

This sucks we need set judges. I mean if people are going to say

"i would have to say that Huy-N's render is better. *XYZ*Tinx's is just a little choppy on some parts (looks like he didn't feather at all) and the usability is low" That is crap judging compared to the judging from 2 rounds ago.

 

HYN
Difficulty 9/10 (the hair looks really hard)
Uniquness - ive seen this done before 7/10
Usability - looks pretty usuable if scaled down 7/10
How Well The Image Has Been Cut 9/10
Size - big

XYZ
Difficulty 8.5/10 (leaves look hard)
Uniquness- also been done but less than other render 7.5/10
Usability- Dont see this being used very much in a sig 6/10
How well the image has been cut 8/10
Size-Big

My vote goes to HYN

 

I vote for the first one.

Difficulty 9/10
Uniquness - 4/10
Usability - 7.5/10
How Well The Image Has Been Cut 9.5/10
Size - 10/10

 

and YOUR vote goes to...........................

 

glad you share the same feelings as I do.

O well, no big deal anyways, It doesnt make any difference to me if I made it to the finals or if I even won the tourny. Not much intrest left in GR

 

*hopes he can vote*

Huy-N's Render.

Difficulty: 9/10 (=|)
Uniquness: 5.5/10 I've seen it done before, and is a little annoying to see again.)
Usability: 7.5/10 (Colour is too pale, sig/tag might be monotoned.)
How Well The Image Has Been Cut: 9.9/10 (so damn good, I can hardly see a flaw.)
Size: 9/10 (huge, but not massive.)

Overall: a nice render for sure, but it's been done before too many times.
Flawlessly cut though.

*XYZ*Tinx's Render.

Difficulty: 9.2/10 (leaves must look hard.)
Uniquness: 9.5/10 (Never seen it before.)
Usability: 6.5/10 (ehhh.........)
How Well The Image Has Been Cut: 8.5/10 (Sloppy in some parts.)
Size: 8.9/10 (slightly cut off.)

Overall: Unique render, but might've been too diffficult to cut for XYZ.
It seemed more like a challenge of "Can I render this?" more then rendering it so it can be used.

My vote goes to Huy-N, it's better cut and is more usable then XYZ's.

Good luck to both of you.

 

damn dude, if i had seen that as your origional youd have gotten my vote no problem, that render would be EXTREMELY hard... and you did and awesome job on it kudos for you.

 

Thats alright, it's not a big deal. However I'm glad you think that

 

First of all I want to say that these guys are awesome in general (respect for you guys) so it is a little bit hard to judge..but I will try

*XYZ*TinX</span>

Difficulty - I think it`s about 8.9/10 because right side was very hard to cut but left side was much more easier however - hard to cut
Uniquness - I have seen it once 9/10
Usability - Very usable for wallpapers,sigs etc. 10/10
How Well The Image Has Been Cut: Really good cut but I see some choppynes on her knees - 8.8/10
Size - Good size 10/10

So my vote goes to <span style=\'color:gold\'>Huy-N but like I said,guys you both are amazing persons..

 

woot, i've made it onto Blzrd's respect list