H2o Vs. Kazuya, Open!

Keep on the battle.

2 - 1 Kazuya.

 

"following my instructions, i'm not going to give in."

I challenged, this is my battle, you follow my instructions.

Masters vote counts. There IS enough detail, what else do you want him to say?



2-3 h2o

 

Where? Point it out?

Also, I find it interesting how I'm at the disadvantage here, No Pen Tool, No Usability Votes & Your being pretty tight with voting too, which Isn't very fair.

If you want a "decent" render battle, you should stick with the basic rules which are fair for everyone, and not just for yourself.

To be honest, I never gave this much thought or try, but I know God didn't plan my fall this early, so I'm staying faithful that I'm gonna pull through this.

 

Dooks.. what are you talking about.. My vote doesnt count? You never wrote a format to write it in.......You simply said these 2 things:

- How Well The Image Was Cut
- Difficult Of Render

My post said:

Both images were cut excellent; but it looks like kazuya's was easier. More or not, the bg dident blend in at all, easier to cut.

Which fully goes along with the guideline you gave. Let me make it more simple for you..

How well the images were cut - Both images were cut excellent;
Difficult Of Render - but it looks like kazuya's was easier. More or not, the bg dident blend in at all, easier to cut.

Perfectly gave you both things you wanted. Btw, edit your 25 spelling/grammar mistakes in this thread before you start expecting perfection.

 

Sigh this is going to lead to a flame war soon...

 

If Masters vote counts its 2 - 2.

Not 2 - 3, majics vote dont count, why? Because YOUR Rules, 20 Reps.

But since, I want detail, Im gonna keep what My vote is.

2 - 2 Kazuya.

My judgement counts.

And dont be so iffy h2o, the battle just started. Sheehs.

Merged Post:

Alright. Vote stands now at 2 - 2.

Now was that so hard?

More votes please.

Merged Post:

Alright. Vote stands now at 2 - 2.

Now was that so hard?

More votes please.

 

look at the bottom of the first page.

 

They are both marvelous renders and have been cut greatly. However, I'm going to have to go Kazuya, although it was a hard decision. For one, I thought h2o had great quality, but wasn't all that usable. However, the cuts on the webs were pretty nice, except there was some choppyness, especially around that leg area. On the other hand, Kazuya's was a very nice cut with all the needles and stuff. The only problem was the quality, but the usability was alright. However, I felt that Kazuya's render was cut better, and that's what I based my vote on.

 

Masters vote + Radiums vote = 2 Votes for you.

BlazeMans + Mafias = 2 votes for kaz.

Get where im goign with this?

2 - 2 Tied.

Merged Post:

Edit, Xarth voted as I was typing.

3 - 2 Kazuya.

Merged Post:

Edit, Xarth voted as I was typing.

3 - 2 Kazuya.

 

go thru all the votes and recount, youll see that its 3-3.

not counting the 2 that dont count.

bottom of the first page......you missed it.


Xarth - I see what you based the vote on, but you didnt even need to type anything about usability since that doesnt matter at all.

 

Just saw that. Didnt notice shawn edited.

Ok, its 3 - 3.

Nice battle so far, more votes please.

 

here kaz:



Its a wierd think to render the inside of something and leave the outline, but when you take that into photoshop you can see how thiiiin the outline is and that you can see thru it, like it was feathered or something.

also notice the chopyness that you KEPT from the orig....wouldnt you think to fix it?

your render doesnt look like it was ONLY polly lassoed to me, sorry.

 

Why are you so uptight about it, cant you have a nice battle?

Its still 3 - 3, if you dont belive kaz, how trustworthy he is, grow up and move to another battle.

Im out for 20 minutes, Ill be back shortly.

it remains 3 - 3.

 

hmm the quality of kaz's cut is breath taking. not to mention its much more detailed and obviously harder.



kaz gmv

 

because rules are rules. you seem pretty uptight about the rules...so why cant I be?

is -Dr.Gonzo-s post enough detail for you or should he re-write it? looks like he has to re-write it.