H2o Vs. Kazuya, Open!

Both images were cut excellent; but it looks like kazuya's was easier. More or not, the bg dident blend in at all, easier to cut.

h20 GMV.

 

Well, its pretty dis-advantaged to me anyway - No Pen Tool + No Usability Voting= Disadvantage to Kazuya.

But I'm not bothered, I'm still confident I'll do well

Good luck ^_^

 

i vote h20...both beautifully cut but i find h2o's harder to render

 

thanks for the vote but you have 9 rep, you need 20 to vote.

 

This is an important battle.

Keep in your post a good and definite reason, and the 2 voting guidelines, Cut, and Difficulty.

If you dont follow by those your vote is not counted.

1 - 0 Kazuya.

 

Ok sorry about the earlier post.

H20's render:

You have a very nice smooth cut all the webs look good and its hardly has any choppyness

Kazuya:

Your render is very smooth and looks great. The cuts are perfect can't find one error.

Very close call but i think that Kazuya's render wins becuase its a more usuable render.

 

Thank you BlaceMan.

Please include that kind of vote people.

2 - 0 Kazuya.

 

H20 is way harder cause all the webs n ----

 

Again, Dont vote unless you can take the 30 seconds to read the post.

2 - 0 Kazuya.

 

Master's vote fit the requirements to be counted as a vote, what are you thinking dooks.

same with majics.....if it says WHY they vooted then it counts....they dont HAVE to writeit out in a special format.

 

Kazuya:

-Cut: It's a pretty nice cut, but it's not very smooth in most areas. Some areas were too thin, some had left over black areas, kinda making it look weird.

-Difficulty: Ooh, the difficulty. I find that his image was really difficult, and he managed to render it pretty well, noting how hard it looks to render.

h2o:

-Cut: A beautiful cut, making it smooth where the web was, but some slight choppyness here and there. Nice cut overall.

-Difficulty: I find that this image was extra hard, considering that there were many closures on the web and such, and also the bottom glow probably made it even more difficult.

h2o gmv.

 

Masters did give a detailed explanation, which I want.

And majic does not have the 20 Reputation votes.

The votes still stand at 2 - 1 Kazuya.

If masters wants to be counted, edit it, or make another reply.

Merged Post:

2 - 1 Kazuya. More Votes please.

 

Master says:
tell him i said i ban him 9,999 days (27 years) if he doesnt count my vote lol

 

Well If I get banned for following my instructions, i'm not going to give in.

The votes stand 2 - 1 Kazuya.

And if master is so worried about it, take the 2 seconds to edit it.

 

kazuya, look at the spike under the first 'KAZUYA EXCLUSIVE' on you render...the tip of it...what is up with that?? why would anyone ever cut out the inside and just leave the outline. fishy.