H2o Vs. Kazuya, Open!

Your Voting on h20 Vs. Kazuya.

Rules:

First to 10 Votes!

- 200 Posts Needed
- 20 Reps Needed

Ways to Judge:
- How Well The Image Was Cut
- Difficult Of Render

Notes
- This Is Poly Gonal Lasso Tooll Only!
- 100 Credits on the Line
- On Kazuyas, It was an exclusive Render in his Render Pack, But the text should not affect the Juding

h2o's Entry:

Original:
http://www.sinsnipers.com/images/renders/weborig.jpg

Render:


Kazuya's Entry:

Original:
http://www.Kazuya.brokenhosting.com/Kazuya...you%20go....jpg

Render:


First to 10, GO! Good Luck.

 

OMG !! this is a dream come true !!

ok lets vote.

h20:

Difficulty:That look's like it was very very hard to cut out with the web and all !! Very nice job.

Cut: Very nice cut, Clean, sharp no errors very nice job.

Kaz:

Difficulty: Same as h2o looks like it was very hard to cut out.

Cut: Very nice clean cut all away around !

----

Ok now, This is one of the hardest votes i have done in quite sometime !

My vote goes to. Kaz GMV that its just that tiny bit more attractive when you look at it.

--edit--

I know you said not to vote but i saw the render before you took it off, i started to write then you put up the dont vote yet ! But yes i saw bnoth renders !!

 

Open.

Voting stands at 1 - 0 Kazuya.

More Votes Please.

 

mafia your vote doesnt count.

 

Not voting but i just want to say:

H2o - I'm dissapointed in that render, looks like you rushed it or something, just not up to your ussual standard.
You didn't render the hair or web at the right and didn't make a attempt at feathering or making any of the web semi transparent
You also cut bits off and the curves seem choppy..

I know you can do better than that

 

its 100% poly lasso. no feathering, no nothing, this is a 100% poly lasso tool battle.

since kaz fixed his stroke around the render, im gonna fix the part you where talking about jkes. i missed that part.

 

^ still.. you didn't cut the hair and left a large block of blue to the right, as well as the web on the right remains un cut :\

 

Juding still stands at 1 - 0 Kazuya.

As long as Voters put in Difficulty, and The cut the vote stands strong.

They can add there own comments in also, just as long as those 2 guidelines are met, the vote holds.

 

Before we continue. I wanna set something straight.

Using the Poly Tool only doesn't mean your better than someone, Pen, Feather, Eraser and etc count too.
We're just using Poly becuz H2o wishes to
Judges SHOULD be able to vote on other factors, but since H2o requested Difficulty and how well its cut, PLEASE only vote on those factors.

Good luck - and this will be a sweet battle

 

there i edited post just to talk about cut and diff, i just added little things here and there to give you guys more pride but w/e

 

Ok now that its set.

Judging Stands at 1 - 0 Kazuya.

More votes please.

 

BlazeMan Please stick to the voting guidelines.

Votes are still 1-0 Kazuya.

 

dooks you put on the first post that this is a pen tool render, its poly lasso.

and that vote SHOULDNT count because that voter was counting the usability also which is bad for me since mine isnt uable. but he/she edited it out now, so w/e.

 

updated*

1 - 0 Kazuya.

 

for sho
h2o
Difficulty: the colors are more closely to together so it looks harder to do
Cut: The cut is like omg my god nice

Kazuya
Difficulty: its doesnt looks to hard to cut but it would take awhile tho
Cut: it looks pretty tight tho gj

GJ Both of you
My Vote Goes To
H2O