I vote for the second one, I don't like the first one, too much brushed, and it is looking very plain. Second one is definetly better ...
Uhm going for the first one.. looks like a wall with sunlight from cracks in a dungeon. With a little blood here and there. Bluesfear I didn't like the text or the scanlines. But nice brushing and render. 1-1
the first one, nice sig.. lovely the second one, im guessing sage, scanlines and render not blended ruin it.... 5-1
is it me or aren't we supposed to vote on the overall look of the sig? i dont care how good his brushing is, i vote second one. 5-2?