Lighting one looks better. Although, try at least colour the light source as oppose to a white soft brush blob. It's so over-done. I love the right hand side, don't like the left. If you'd kept the right hand style all the way through it'd be better for it.
hmm okay i like the right side a lot too. But on this 1 i might just leave it like this and try that on a new one instead. Thanks for input bro