Edgar90 Vs Tonkpils Vs Liquid_

cool lets start first 7 wins...

Liquid_



tonkpils



Edgar90



20 crez from looser too winner

 

Liquid's sig looks a little plain and I don't like all the open space around his text.

Edgar 90's sig is nice but I don't think the video adds to it overall. Also, the green wash doesn't really do it for me and the edges where the sig becomes transparent are rather choppy.

Tonkpils' sig sports a horribly over-used render but is (in my eyes) the superior sig. The text blends well and compliments the BG. The render is blended well and alhtough I htink the yellow tendrils at the bottom are a bit bright I feel that they add more than they detract.

Liquid - Tonkpil - Edgar
0-1-0

 

Edgar90 hase my vot the concept is very nice, very origanal atleast as far as i know,

Liquid - Tonkpil - Edgar
0-1-1

 

First one was to simple in opinion, edgars was nice i liked the concept but my vote goes to tonks due to blending and time taken Blitz
0-2-1

 

Tonk.

Im just really feeling it: Unlike the others.

 

Flames I guess you voted for tonk so with my vote for edgars it goes to 0-3-2

 

i go for edgars. im just feeling it.


0-3-3

 

i'll go for edgar.. i like this style..
0-3-4

 

My vote goes to Tonk as well. Liquid's your is just too plain, maybe a little more grunge or something. Edgar's is unique though very choppy around the render and some other parts of the sig. The video in it.. I just have no idea what is going on since it is animated quickly.

0-4-4

 

I vote for tonks
his blending is cool and semi-matches the backround
good going tonk who has no life outdoors...lol

-Game

 

i vote for tonk because i liked the render, and i liked how the text blended in with the BG...

 

Funny how 2 people come out of the blue with like 1 post and vote for Tonk.

 

edgar.....like the originality of it

 

0-6-5 one more for tonk 2 more for me...

 

And look how they both attached their sigs! LOOK at their render <_< Someone's cheaaattttinngg.