Demon_lord Vs. Titan.

Losers Bracket

Renders will be judged on:
Difficulty
How unique the render is
Usability - IS A MAJOR FACTOR!!
How Well The Image Has Been Cut
Size - NOTE This Is Not A Major Factor.

Demon_Lord:

Original:

http://www.exoload.net/106/1136589848.jpg

Rendered:



Titan.

original:

http://img361.imageshack.us/img361/1176/wa...yviiadvent1.jpg

rendered:

 

JUDGES MAY VOTE HERE NOW

 

I'm really anxious to get started with voting on these spectacular renders

Demon_lord

Great job with the render and I think it looks quite difficult, say 8/10 or so. It's quite large but not necessarily practical for much beyond impractical graphics. The cut around the "cape" of the lower character is ... decent but not great. The beam was done nicely though and that stands out in this render great work!

Titan

All those tiny squares - you must be mad! Nice job on that, especially although they were slightly unevenly done. Around 9/10 would be an appropriate difficulty rating for this, since the hair was rather nicely done and i like it! The overall cut is great and I love how you rendered the curves in it - it's really great. Beyond signatures and web graphics, it's quite small for larger graphics. This render is great

My vote goes to...

*drum roll*

Titan.! Great work and amazing render! I've actually been looking for a render of this particular image and I was glad to find such an extraordinary cut of it! Great work!

~nightfire

 

Both renders are done excellently.

Demon_Lord: Awesome rendering on raziel's sword. Those effects just look great. Very smooth on the rest of the rendering.

Titan: Great render, those squares must have taken forever. But I don't think doing all those squares are as difficult as rendering the smoke effects on the sword like demon lord did.

Demon_Lord GMV

 

demon lord got my vote.
really good and more difficult
titan good but nobody would use it.

 

edit: No demon_lord doesnt get my vote. When I looked at it some more its pretty choppy in some parts + outline.

Titan gmv

 

Demon Lord : especially the beam has been cut perfectly, but at Titans his is just overall very nice. Hard decision but becuz of the nice fading of the beam i fell in love with it and my vote goes to Demon Lord =).

 

1st:
With the sword it this looks like a hard cut; you did the sword part extremely well; too bad the rest is a little bit choppy.
2nd:
This render has already been whored to the max; i've seen it in so many sigs now. The cutting is quite good; except the hair.

My vote goes to Demon_Lord, a really hard picture with the flaming sword, and i've not seen it many times before.

 

to both renderers well done great job..

RENDER A.....Demon_Lord

nice cut overall bit choopy on the hair but nothing major would of been good to clone out the text and the hand on the cape though.Difficulty i would say 7/10 nice size too.Useability isnt to high though and could be a factor.

RENDER B.....Titan
Nice cut can see a lot wrong with it only little things like the hand with a bit of bg left on it but nothing really to worry about.Difficulty is a 8/10 tedious job on the squares,nice size.Usability is middle of the road i would say.

MY VOTE GOES TO.....

TITAN.... very close call but the sheer time that this render must have taken and the great blending on them too has won it for me..

GREAT JOB TO YOU BOTH VERY NICE RENDERS.

 

Demon Lords was great but he could of did a better job on kain because he is a little choppy..but raziel and his sword were great..

Titans was nice to..a nice smooth effect

-Titan gj

 

although both renders are very well cut and have their difficult parts, the part off the sword for demon_lord and the boxes for titan, i feel titans is more usable. Titan gets my vote.

 

Demon Lord GMV. That was a MUCH harder render to cut. Although both cuts are great, I believe DL's is a better render.

 

5 - 4 So far, I Demon_Lord needs atlest 1 or 2 more votes to secure a win!

 

Demon_Lord

Difficulty - medium
How unique the render is - seen before
Usability - Low with the botom guy, high with just the top dood.
Cut - The glow is quite nice, not too clean. the cut itself is choppy in places like the top of the head. also the white areas of the blade to the right look a little out of place imo.
Size - Good size.

Titan

Difficulty - high
How unique the render is - uniqueville
Usability - as you can see by all the sigs that have used it - VERY HIGH.
Cut - A realy good, clean cut, the top and corner squares look abit bad though also the right arm is choppy.
Size - Good.

------
My vote goes to.......
------
*drum roll*
------
scroll down.
------
keep going..
------
Titan

.. I feel you set yourself a challenge and pulled it off very nicely

 

Titan's on the comeback!!

Comon!!