ok lets see, the quality of the sig is amazing, you can tell alot more work was put into it, and the coloring is very nice... overall it looks alot better than the other one that is one solid color 1-0
The first one... Hands down. That was one of the best I've seen from you RagnaroK, and VDeath, of course. The colours were amazing, the render was perfect, the blending was hot! The second one was great, don't get me wrong, but the first is better.
1-1 my vote goes to the second one. I really like the text effect and actually i think the solid color fits the sig really well. Lookin good !
I like the second one better because the colour choice fit the render + nice effect on the background.' 2-2