i like Blood's, it seems like he worked a bit more with it, i also like how simple the font is but its still effect -gj to both of you and goodluck.
Blood 2-2 If you colored your sig more accordingly with your render it would look more solid. But on the whole I think it looks better than Midnights personally.
I had the background matched with the render but I changed it. Only reason was because with an orange and lime green background it's just too bright