I prefer the second. But I dont like the result, the lights are good, but I only see some layers duplicated, and the renders.. :/ effects not much,
too big, I think u are new at Design, cause ur effects are so primary, some wrong aplication, but if u read some tutoriais, u will be better. :D...
Hum, I dont like that highlights at top, looks star wars.. so much I prefer only the char and down effects..
First is better, cause the other has some wrong details. I really dont like ur tipograph.. :X But the result looks nice
Humm, dunno, its good, but not very very.. I dont like the down effects.. But u are almost there ;D
Separate names with a comma.