The render could be blended in better, or a better render could've been chosen... it just doesn't seem to match the background for some reason....
First one - 9/10 second - 7.5/10
You should blend the render a bit on the first two..6.75/10 for both.
7.5/10 In my humble opinion, the render should be a bit more blended..
Separate names with a comma.